Do what thou wilt shall be the whole of the Law.
In general, there are three broad systems of belief. These are:
-
Theism: the belief in the existence of Spiritual Beings such as gods, angels, or demons;
-
Atheism: the belief that Spiritual Beings do not exist; and
-
Agnosticism: the acknowledgment that one does not know whether spiritual beings exist or not.
Now, certain spiritual beliefs are not, generally, considered to be theistic. Theravāda, a form of early (or Nikāya) Buddhism, along with some forms of Mahāyāna and Vajrayāna Buddhism fall into this category. Many feel that doctrinal Taoism, rather than folk Taoism, belongs to this realm as well.
However, strictly speaking, these are not always atheistic, as they often postulate the existence of the non-material. The Western term “religion” has problems with spiritual traditions that are not a part of the Abrahamic religions.
These are some of the reasons why Crowley stated in Magick Without Tears: “Call it a new religion, …; but I confess that I fail to see what you will have gained by so doing, and I feel bound to add that you might easily cause a great deal of misunderstanding, and work a rather stupid kind of mischief”.
Spiritual Tradition is more cumbersome, but far less restrictive. Unfortunately, it does carry a mild pejorative as it is often used by dilettantes unwilling to commit to, or even really understand, the traditions they claim to be following.
Thelema contains references to several gods and goddesses. Nuit, Hadit, Heru-Ra-Ha, Pan, Babalon, and Therion are referenced regularly. The rituals we use refer to YHVH, Adonai, Ehieh (Asher Ehieh), and various angels, such as Aiwass, Gabriel, Raphiel, Michael, and Uriel. We can continue, the list is legion.
However, we must remember Crowley’s words in Liber O, where he states “It is immaterial whether these exist or not. By doing certain things certain results will follow; students are most earnestly warned against attributing objective reality or philosophic validity to any of them”.
Back to Magick Without Tears, we are told that Thelema is “an enthusiastic putting-together of a series of doctrines, no one of which must in any way clash with Science or Magick.” Thelema seems to postulate the “Gods” as an operational jargon. When I refer to “Yahweh” it conjures an energy/symbol/archetype/being defined by the Tetragrammaton, whose qualities are known and defined through various techniques — since it refers to a Hebrew term, these are mostly Qabalistic methods.
We are skeptical, which means we doubt both the Theist and the Atheist. The proper Thelemic view would be agnosticism, neither denying nor believing in the existence of the Gods. Even the Creed of Liber XV: The Gnostic Catholic Mass was written so that it could be read in a strictly atheistic manner.
Properly speaking, Thelema tells us to determine the truth for ourselves. Crowley, who had practiced Theravāda Buddhism prior to his revelation, came to feel “My observation of the Universe convinces me that there are beings of intelligence and power of a far higher quality than anything we can conceive of as human; that they are not necessarily based on the cerebral and nervous structures that we know; and that the one and only chance for mankind to advance as a whole is for individuals to make contact with such Beings.1” As noted earlier, Theravāda is a form of Nikāya Buddhism.
Likewise, I progressed from a virulent anti-Christian atheism to where I am today, which is usually a theistic leaning agnostic. I have had direct, personal, revelatory experiences with gods, goddesses, and the divine. However, this is subjective. They are my experiences and I cannot prove them to anyone else, nor do I try. Anecdotal experience is not proof. Neither can I prove that my personal subjective experiences were not delusion or misinterpretation. However, I felt pretty silly referring to myself as an atheist after I had met god.
I have found that many atheists are as committed to swaying others to their belief system as fundamentalist Christians are.
The closest I have for “proof” of the divine are the Principle of Grandeur and the fact that The Whole is Greater than the Sum of Its Parts. These are actually related, which may or may not be obvious from their descriptions.
The first is an animistic viewpoint. In fact, it is a principle behind the Japanese Shinto tradition. In the land of infinite gods, anything that imbues a sense of awe or wonder is considered a god. The spirits of place can inhabit a valley, a river, a stone, or a tree. Anything that creates a response in the minds of the viewer is a god. Nor is it restricted to natural items. The beauty of a Gothic cathedral, the ubiquitousness of the Compact Disk, these are also gods. Gods also go away when that which created them goes away. The CD god is weakening. When a river is paved over, its god is diminished (this was the origin of Haku in the movie Spirited Away). The death or diminishment of a god isn’t always simple. The negative impacts are alluded to in Miyazaki’s Princess Mononoke.
The second “proof” revolves around the simple fact that while we know the composition of the human body, if we take all of these elements and mix them together, we would not have a human being. In a similar vein, when we take various colors and apply them to canvas, a thing of beauty emerges. This isn’t a call for intelligent design per se, it in no way attempts to deny the reality of evolution. However, there is, as Liber AL: II:32 puts it, “a factor infinite & unknown”. It is in this infinite and unknown factor that I see the face of God.
So, to put it simply, Thelema is skeptical of the claims put forth by both Atheism and Theism. However, Thelemites generally hold that there is something “plus” to the material realm. Having said that, there are self-identified Thelemites who hold either position, but (for the most part) they seem to be rather conflicted in their opinions and specious in their arguments.
I will end with two chapter-poems from Crowley’s The Book of Lies.
CHINESE MUSIC
"Explain this happening!"
"It must have a `natural' cause." \/ "It must have a `supernatural' cause."
Let these two asses be set to grind corn.
May, might, must, should, probably, may be, we may safely assume, ought, it is hardly questionable, almost certainly-poor hacks! let them be turned out to grass!
Proof is only possible in mathematics, and mathematics is only a matter of arbitrary conventions.
And yet doubt is a good servant but a bad master; a perfect mistress, but a nagging wife.
"White is white" is the lash of the overseer: "white is black" is the watchword of the slave. The Master takes no heed.
The Chinese cannot help thinking that the octave has 5 notes.
The more necessary anything appears to my mind, the more certain it is that I only assert a limitation.
I slept with Faith, and found a corpse in my arms on awaking; I drank and danced all night with Doubt, and found her a virgin in the morning.
TERRIER-WORK
Doubt.
Doubt thyself.
Doubt even if thou doubtest thyself.
Doubt all.
Doubt even if thou doubtest all.
It seems sometimes as if beneath all conscious doubt there lay some deepest certainty. O kill it! Slay the snake!
The horn of the Doubt-Goat be exalted
Dive deeper, ever deeper, into the Abyss of Mind, until thou unearth the fox THAT. On, hounds!
Yoicks! Tally-ho! Bring THAT to bay!
Then, wind the Mort!
—-
Truth is found in the rubble of falsehood.
Love is the law, love under will.
-
Chapter XXXI: Religion–Is Thelema a "New Religion"?
https://hermetic.com/crowley/magick-without-tears/mwt_31 -
Liber O vel Manus et Sagittae sub figurâ VI
https://hermetic.com/crowley/libers/lib6 -
Liber XV: Ecclesiæ Gnosticæ Catholicæ Canon Missæ
https://hermetic.com/crowley/libers/lib15 -
Chapter XXX: Do you believe in God?
https://hermetic.com/crowley/magick-without-tears/mwt_30 -
Haku
http://spiritedaway.wikia.com/wiki/Haku_(Nigihayami_Kohaku_Nushi) -
Princess Mononoke
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Princess_Mononoke -
Liber AL vel Legis sub figurâ CCXX as Delivered By XCIII = 418 to DCLXVI
https://hermetic.com/crowley/libers/lib220 -
Book of Lies “Chinese Music” and “Terrier-Work”
https://hermetic.com/crowley/libers/lib333
1 Aleister Crowley, Magick Without Tears, “Chapter XXX: Do you believe in God?” https://www.bibliotecapleyades.net/crowley/mwt/mwt_30.htm